Who's Right?

In today's PPH, Matt Wickenheiser writes:

Collins said the country hasn't struck the right balance in regulation. She charged that Allen opposed two amendments in 2005 that would have strengthened regulation of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. Allen responded that the bill passed the House, with his vote, but died in the Senate.

There are two options possibilities.

1. Collins and Allen are talking past each other--they're referencing different bills.

2. One of them is lying.

Why won't PPH tell us which one it is? Is everyone over there too overworked to think straight? Is it laziness? An indifference to the truth?